This site is reader-supported. When you click through links on our site, we may be compensated.
There are theories, of course: Maybe the 127-year-old magazine still isn't ready for a face tattoo on the cover and it was photoshopped out, or Justin got it removed months ago per his new wife's request (remember when she told him to ditch his mustache?), or maybe his long-time groomer, Florido, simply covered it with a little concealer. We still don't even know whether JonBoy or McCurdy is responsible, since neither of the artists have confirmed nor denied their part in it.